© 2011 Great New Story
The New Grand Narrative
The New Grand Narrative
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Written by: Bob Brinsmead
Wendell’s comments on this site have fired my imagination for the emergence of A Grand New Narrative. A new grand narrative is essential for the emerge of a humanized future. This is the discussion we need to be involved in. Others have had this vision of hope, like Campbell and the author of the “Emergence of Everything”, but human society is still living by the old narratives of the last two thousand years. A new narrative has not yet emerged in the human arena. Everything from Christianity, to Marxism (this includes all world religions including Islamic religions and world political movements) are rehashes of the old narrative based on myth and apocalyptic.
A new grand narrative will be based on reality not myth. It will grab the human imagination bringing hope and universal unconditional love. It will not be new wine in old bottles. Religion of any form cannot hold the new narrative. All religion puts conditions on love and acceptance.
Our first discussion needs to be why we need a new narrative. We need to discuss the negatives of the old narrative in order to appreciate and understand the grandness of the New Narrative. The New Narrative will excite the human imagination and humanize human existence. It will bring in a new human order. It will take away all fear of death while delivering contentment to live life to it’s fullest while serving in this physical state of existence. Like those who have had a new death experience, human society will have an experience of ultimate love and know that everything will be alright in the end. It has been well documented how the fear of death holds humanity captive. The new narrative will deliver people from this fear of death.
A young lady asked me, “What is a new grand narrative and is God part of this narrative? Has this grand narrative ever been told before?”
My reply was, “Yes this narrative was told in a local sense by the Old Testament prophets. The prophet's narrative was based on the exodus. The prophet’s story was a vision of hope not because of what was, but because of the potential of what could be. They told their narrative against the backdrop of oppression and discouragement. Their story was of the God who acted on behalf of the oppressed. The land, this oppressed people were given, was a stony desert like country with the Jordon running through it like a miserable creek, compared to the mighty Tigris or Euphrates of the other prosperous nations. This vision of the prophets for a better future eventually spread to the other nations, like the Greeks who had their vision of potential. Socrates died because he tried to dispel the Greek myths in order to have a more realistic narrative.
Now another illustration of a narrative is my father coming to Queensland years ago. You know to be human is to live in story. For humanity to progress to a more human future, we must live in story and we need a Grand New Narrative as Wendell said. I see even in the newspapers this end of year, there is comment that this Government needs a narrative to catch the vision of the people. Well back to us coming to Queensland. My father came back to where we were living in Victoria, from his visit to Queensland with a grand story of a land flowing with tropical fruit and mighty potential. He packed us all up and in a hired truck sitting on a mattress with us boys in the back and Mum in the front beside the driver, we drove for two weeks to come to the bush farm in Numinbah. The road got rougher and rougher and we eventually arrived to find rugged, stony hills and a bush shack with two rooms. Mum shook her fist at Father and said, “You old brute what have you brought us to?” Father told her again of the Grand story, it was a story of potential, of hope, of what could be. The Grand Story of human potential is a story against what seems hopeless. This is a story against the dark backdrop of evolution. It is the negative that makes the Grand Narrative shine so brightly and grab the imagination. This is a story of the God who disappeared in the human arena to bring human society to its grand potential against all odds.
The Jewish history then became a history of discouragement that the Narrative of the prophets was not happening. So apocalyptic was born to explain the disappointment and redefine the narrative as only having potential at the end of the age. So this apocalyptic movement was born based on a story of a fall, a separation from God that destroyed the vision of the prophets. Jesus rejected this apocalyptic and re-ignited the prophet’s narrative of human potential and rejected the notion of humanity separated from the Divine.
The world is waiting for the emergence of a new story. Religion has been shown not to produce any better behavior than non-religion. Love and discipline is seen in the non-religious who don’t have the Christian narrative . When we were running institutes in USA, a Baptist guy was the caretaker and asked me did I believe in Hell. When I said no, he was wild and responded that if what I believed was true then he might as well have all the fun he wanted. His narrative controlled his behavior through fear of not pleasing a vengeful God. This coercion can’t humanize for a future of human potential and freedom.
Links:
Post your comment
Comments
-
In his, "Rational Optimist", Ridley notes the grand sweep of human history and how progress has been central to this history. But there is still the need for an overarching narrative to explain this progress, a larger story that will penetrate human consciousness and sub-consciousness. A narrative that will deal with the big questions people wonder and ask about, questions of why and meaning. This overarching narrative will inspire and enable even more of this progress. It should deal with the themes of the old narrative, exposing their fallacy and damaging impacts on human consciousness and behaviour. It will offer clear alternatives. It will get even more to the root of things.
Below are a list of contrasting themes of grand narratives (just a sample)- one the dominant narrative in human consciousness from the past (Old Narrative) and the other a new narrative based on what humanity has discovered over the past few centuries to be the true nature of reality and life. These themes express the background ideas that shape the basic human orientation toward life and influence human emotions, thinking, and responses to life.
Central to the new narrative is the long trajectory of the rising progress of life toward something better. This is undeniable. All of the history of life is evidence of this, as is the history of human civilization. Why life rises and progresses toward something better will make sense in terms of people’s varied philosophical positions. Matt Ridley explains the rise in terms of his views of evolutionary theory. He notes well the varied steps and developing practices that promoted the ongoing rise. Others will explain the rising progress in terms of love seeking something better or the fundamental human desire for something better than what exists now. This impulse is behind all creativity and innovation. To find some solution to some disease or problem and to make life easier and better for oneself, one’s family, and one’s community or for humanity as a whole. Goodness, generosity, and love (expressions of a similar basic impulse) seek expression through improving life and the human situation. This primal impulse cannot be contained. It will burst forth somehow to continue the rising progress of life toward something better than what exists now.
To put this in metaphysical terms- the core of reality and life is some transcendent Love that must find expression in life. This is the most plausible explanation. There is nothing angry, malicious, threatening or frightening at the core of reality and life. This too is central to a new grand narrative.
The list of contrasts below is to help show what exactly it is that we need to leave in terms of basic themes that inform our consciousness and sub-consciousness and shape our orientation toward life.
1. A. Old Narrative- Perfect origin, then a fall and subsequent decline toward something worse.
B. New Narrative- Imperfect origin, no fall, and subsequent continued rise toward something better. This progressing rise has been slow but steady over the long term. One can understand this further in terms of freedom. There is no coercion, but divine toleration and patience with human development (no Noahic impatience and destructive anger with human imperfection). People are free and responsible to make something better out of life. And it is always a work in progress. Such progress involves suffering and struggle as essential to learning. It is a free process because only genuine freedom can produce the genuine moral choice and goodness so valued by divinity.
2. A. Old Narrative- Devalues and demeans humanity as responsible for the fall and decline of life. Humanity is defiled, corrupt, dark and selfish, and destructive. This is the essential nature of being human.
B. New Narrative- Humanity as embodied consciousness is a wonder that is essentially love and light. Human persons are most essentially compassion (this is our true self). People are creative on balance, not destructive. We have not caused any fall or decline in life.
3. A. Old Narrative- Humanity as corrupted is responsible for causing a cosmic separation from the creating Source. This has led to rejection of humanity by that Creator. If human rejection by parents/family has devastating impacts on people’s psyche, how much more devastating is the belief that human being are rejected by their Creator/Father.
B. New Narrative- There has never been any separation of humanity from God, no rejection by God. There is absolutely no evidence of such a separation accompanied by the ruin of nature (the sudden simultaneous emergence of death, thorns, sweat glands and crawling snakes in the fossil strata).
4. A. Old Narrative- The ruptured relationship with the divine requires a salvation scheme. This involves sudden divine intervention to restore what was ruptured based on theories of atonement (that blood sacrifice- violent suffering and death of innocent victim- is required to appease infinite divine requirements). Lost original perfection will be restored from outside of humanity. God will restore by overpowering action to clean up the mess humanity has made of things.
B. New Narrative- No salvation is required because no rupture has occurred. Life has since the beginning been about slow steady improvement, advance, development, and progress. Humanity is genuinely free and responsible for the improvement of life and the world. There will be no outside salvation scheme (divine intervention to rescue). Humanity has done just fine in ‘saving’ life.
5. A. Old Narrative- Life and the world will soon end in some catastrophic collapse as punishment for the sin of humanity.
B. New Narrative- There is absolutely no evidence of any coming catastrophic collapse of life. All evidence points to ongoing rise and progress. All the long term trends support this trajectory of progress.
6. A. Old Narrative- Engenders guilt, shame, fear, pessimism and despair. It leads to hatred of self (being human), hatred of life and the world, rejection of these, risk averseness and endeavours to escape life. The old narrative fosters the attitude of longing for the past, preferring the old, preferring stasis to avoid further decline.
B. New Narrative- Engenders hope, confidence, self-acceptance as a wondrous creature, embracing of life, love, hope, confidence in the future. The new narrative fosters the attitude of seeking change and something new as essential to furthering progress into the open and limitless future.
Wendell Krossa
Posted by Wendell Krossa, 29/03/2011 4:55am (1 year ago)
-
Dreams are the beginning of creation, every great idea, product, service, music or art has its roots in dreams.
I think the fact that we spend 1/3 of our lives dreaming, is probably a testament to what our real capabilities as humans are. Dreaming is a very special and different state of consciousness - one in which we can explore possibilities.
I remember asking a man who took on projects restoring old classic buildings in Phoenix what it was that caused it all to come together. I was a carpenter all of 22 years old. Was it good plans? Good banker? Construction knowledge? He said "Its the idea! If you have a good idea, other people will join to help it along. You'd be surprised to learn how rare good ideas are in this world."
Self-organizing collectives are forming in the middle east as we speak!
Life without the hierarchical human pyramids.
Posted by Bill Ferguson, 29/03/2011 4:40am (1 year ago)
-
This thing of new grand narrative.
I have been looking at material on grand historical narratives- their core elements- to further flesh out the shape of where human public consciousness has been oriented over the past and where human consciousness might be going now. This can be summed up in the two narratives of decline or progress. The past grand narrative that governed human public consciousness for millennia has been the narrative of decline. That there was an original golden age or time or purity and power or vitality. Then humans committed an original error and consequently ruined things. Since then life has been in decline toward something worse and is headed for some future catastrophic end of all which will then result in the restoration of the original purity, power, or golden age with more vital human beings, restored to their original purity and power. But decline is the essential trajectory of all things in the old narrative.
It appears now that the Enlightenment birthed the discovery of the beginnings of an entirely new view of life, not as in decline, but as a trajectory of ongoing progress toward something better. This was the beginning of a radical break with the old narrative that had so long governed human consciousness. And yes, Nisbet may have unearthed some earlier intimations of thought in the direction of progress views but they were not all that clear as during the Enlightenment. So Herb, here is your Tower of Truth moment occurring some four centuries ago.
And it was not all just about technological advancement or economic advancement. This occurred in concert with great advances in human consciousness and the human spirit related to increasing value for basic human rights. It was the beginning of a broader move toward a more humane society or existence.
Modern thinkers have continued this movement toward a new grand narrative of progress. They do so with detailed data on long term trends that all show improvement. Simon, Lomberg, Easterbrook, Goklany, Ridley, Payne, Seabright, and many others have offered fascinating data here. But they still could benefit from work on a larger overall context to buttress their work. This could be more empirical and also more oriented toward basic issues of meaning (taking account of the Jewish thinker who argued that the impulse for meaning was the fundamental human impulse, even more foundational than the drives for food or sex or similar survival drives).
In this regard I think of the summarizing statement of John- “God is Love” (for those uncomfortable with the term God, substitute Universal Consciousness or Self, or universal Mind or Spirit or something similar). This is the most profound statement of human understanding and insight ever set forth. It encompasses all of reality as we know it. Whether fundamental physical reality and its emergence, formation and development or anything else. Why a universe friendly to life? Because of unconditional love at the core of all reality. It makes the fullest sense of all things. Why something? Where is it going? What is the point of it all? At the end of the day when we have shelved all the data that we have amassed on the physical world, we still want these fundamental questions of meaning answered also.
God is love will finally break the last vestiges of fear, despair, pessimism, and other darkening elements that continue to fester in human consciousness. Unconditional love is the most fundamental reality behind all else.
And it is not any form of love as we have known it. It is a radical new form of love- unconditional. This overturns millennia of thinking on justice that has been oriented to punishment, revenge, retaliation and such. Tit for tat. This God is unconditional Love lets in a burst of inexpressible light that scatters all the shadows still lingering in public consciousness from millennia of old narrative perceptions.
Anyway, just some thoughts as we continue to tinker with this core narrative issue.
Posted by Wendell Krossa, 27/03/2011 2:14pm (1 year ago)
-
The Great New story is all about infinite, incomprehensible love and light which is the core of reality and at the core of the universe. Physicist tell us that light is the core reality behind all else. It has also been said that love is behind all. Both are the same brilliant reality of love and light that we can’t even begin to comprehend. This will drive out all darkness and despair. This is what the new narrative expresses through its varied themes.
Posted by Carlene Allen, 27/03/2011 3:04am (1 year ago)
-
The Grand New Story keeps coming back to grip my imagination and fire my spirit. We have been making some absolutely amazing discoveries over the past few years and it has all been coming together and toward this insight - conquering the final monster and enemy, death. We have been given such light and liberation. And it is very much a reality based narrative- liberation to live fully in this material world and fulfill the mission or purpose for which our Creator has embedded us here for this short experience of life. To learn something of unconditional love.
We have this great story to tell, a story of light, liberation, love. I so much want to get on with this in this new year. And to bring others along for the joy ride.
Posted by Wendell Krossa, 27/03/2011 2:59am (1 year ago)
-
Much of humanity has been stuck in the old imagination of, "What does God think of me"? Sheehan swept all that thinking away when he said, "God has disappeared." so there is no point in searching, discussing or imaging what God thinks of me. The search for God is over. Centuries of searching for God has been futile as Karen Armstrong’s book, "A History of God" so aptly demonstrates.
So where do we get a concept of what this God who has disappeared in humanity is like? We take the highest attribute in the human arena and by observing this attribute we can know the nature of this incarnated God. Love in its ultimate expression keeps no scores of wrongs and is not self centered. Love unconditionally accepts the other. There was never a time when God ceased to love us. Love is eternal without beginning and without end. In the beginning love's eternal purpose meant that before the world was there was the glory I had with the father. This by-passes all the exclusiveness of the Christian religion. What Jesus said in this statement of the glory he had with the father was a statement that was applicable to all humanity. Sheehan came to this great insight. This understanding swept away the notion of Christianity that God was in a single location. God was not found in a book or ritual but he was manifested in human flesh, that is in the human arena. This is not navel gazing, as we find in much religion but is an objective thing because it relates to the other. We see God's attributes in the neighbor, especially in the great arena of humanity. No exclusivity here. The old kings claimed to be the incarnation of God which was a distorted truth, they made it exclusive.
Now those relating a "Near Death Experiences" maybe discounted by some as an apoptotic brain suffering oxygen deprivation. However this can't explain the lucidness where the person in this experience is observing and knowing minute details of what is occurring, in an out of the body experience. I’ve had a similiar revelation without a dying experience. In the course of life there has been this same confirmation of our ultimate destiny and existence in love. This is an experience in divine love that enables a person to say, live and act within the framework, “It is going to turn out alright in the end.” Some would say if it is going to turn out alright in the end then why the need to know these things? There is great value in living life with such an assurance. In this world of suffering, it is a much more enjoyable ride, in the knowledge of eternal love that has no beginning and no end. One lives with no worry of what God thinks of me. It also enables a person to live in freedom without judgment on the other.Posted by Robert D. Brinsmead, 27/03/2011 2:43am (1 year ago)
-
Much of humanity has been stuck in the old imagination of, "What does God think of me"? Sheehan swept all that thinking away when he said, "God has disappeared." so there is no point in searching, discussing or imaging what God thinks of me. The search for God is over. Centuries of searching for God has been futile as Karen Armstrong’s book, "A History of God" so aptly demonstrates.
So where do we get a concept of what this God who has disappeared in humanity is like? We take the highest attribute in the human arena and by observing this attribute we can know the nature of this incarnated God. Love in its ultimate expression keeps no scores of wrongs and is not self centered. Love unconditionally accepts the other. There was never a time when God ceased to love us. Love is eternal without beginning and without end. In the beginning love's eternal purpose meant that before the world was there was the glory I had with the father. This by-passes all the exclusiveness of the Christian religion. What Jesus said in this statement of the glory he had with the father was a statement that was applicable to all humanity. Sheehan came to this great insight. This understanding swept away the notion of Christianity that God was in a single location. God was not found in a book or ritual but he was manifested in human flesh, that is in the human arena. This is not navel gazing, as we find in much religion but is an objective thing because it relates to the other. We see God's attributes in the neighbor, especially in the great arena of humanity. No exclusivity here. The old kings claimed to be the incarnation of God which was a distorted truth, they made it exclusive.
An experience in divine love enables a person to say, live and act within the framework, “It is going to turn out alright in the end.” Some would say if it is going to turn out alright in the end then why the need to know these things? There is great value in living life with such an assurance. In this world of suffering, it is a much more enjoyable ride, in the knowledge of eternal love that has no beginning and no end. One lives with no worry of what God thinks of me. It also enables a person to live in freedom without judgment on the other. To love and be loved is the conclusion of the whole matter.
Posted by Robert D. Brinsmead, 23/03/2011 3:37am (1 year ago)
-
Let me add that the historical Jesus got the new narrative quite well. His core teaching and parables emphasize unconditional love like no one ever before him- scandalous inclusion of all, unlimited generosity toward all, unlimited forgiveness toward all, no payback, no retribution or punishment, and no requirements to be met before experiencing unconditional love. This theme of unconditional love is so central and so primary and so absolutely essential to the new narrative and understanding what it means to be human (the central issue of all existence and life). This is what the cosmos, life and human experience is all about. We exist to learn and experience unconditional love. The entire cosmos exists to provide an environment for us to learn and experience this within. It explains the purpose of existence and life like nothing else does.
All the writing on near death experiences also affirms this insight. The ones that clearly see this are most helpful. Others also see this but then interpret it in terms of their own religious beliefs which often end up distorting this core element. But that is divine freedom. We are not overwhelmed or coerced into suddenly changing our beliefs, not even in the next life. We still learn and grow and develop within divine patience.
Posted by Wendell Krossa, 23/03/2011 3:30am (1 year ago)
RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments
